| Hon. Mitchell K. Shick, Circuit Judge |
| Hon. Brien J. O’Brien, Circuit Judge |
| Hon. Mark E. Bovard, Circuit Judge |
| Hon. Brian L. Bower, Circuit Judge |
| Hon. Christopher L. Wetzel, Associate Judge |
| Term | Name | City / Notes |
|---|---|---|
| At Large Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1897–1996: three positions | 1996–Present: four positions | ||
| 1897-1902 | Ferdinand Bookwalter | Danville |
| 1897-1903 | Henry Van Sellar | Paris |
| 1897-1903 | Frank K. Dunn | Charleston |
| 1902-1915 | Morton W. Thompson | Danville |
| 1903-1909 | James W. Craig | Mattoon |
| 1903-1915 | E. R. E. Kimbrough | Danville |
| 1909-1915 | William B. Scholfield | Marshall |
| 1915-1927 | Augustus A. Partlow | Danville |
| 1915-1927 | Walter Brewer | Toledo |
| 1915-1927 | John H. Marshall | Charleston |
| 1927-1933 | S. Murray Clark | Danville |
| 1927-1933 | Charles A. Shuey | Charleston |
| 1927-1951 | George W. Bristow | Paris |
| 1933-1935 | Craig Van Meter | Mattoon |
| 1933-1949 | Casper S. Platt | Danville |
| 1936-1939 | Grendel F. Bennett | Marshall |
| 1939-1957 | Ben F. Anderson | Charleston |
| 1951-1963 | John F. Spivey | Danville |
| 1951-1963 | Robert F. Cotton | Paris |
| 1957-1963 | Harry I. Hannah | Mattoon |
| Spivey Judgeship | ||
| 1964-1971 | John F. Spivey | Danville |
| 1971-1979 | Frank J. Meyer | Danville |
| 1980-1985 | John P. Meyer | Danville |
| 1986 | Matthew A. Jurczak | Danville |
| 1986-1996 | Rita B. Garman | Danville |
| 1997-2016 | Claudia S. Anderson | Danville |
| 2017- | Charles C. Hall | Danville |
| Cotton Judgeship | ||
| 1964-1971 | Robert F. Cotton | Paris |
| 1972-1998 | Ralph S. Pearman | Paris |
| 1998-2022 | James R. Glenn | Mattoon |
| 2022- | Brian L. Bower | Charleston |
| Hannah Judgeship | ||
| 1964-1973 | Harry I. Hannah | Mattoon |
| 1973-1980 | Thomas M. Burke | Charleston |
| 1980-2001 | Paul C. Komada | Charleston |
| 2001- | Mitchell K. Shick | Charleston |
| Cini Judgeship | ||
| 1996-2008 | Dale A. Cini | Mattoon |
| 2008-2010 | Richard E. Scott | Paris |
| 2010- | Matthew L. Sullivan | Paris |
| Clark County Judges | ||
| Judges of Probate | ||
| 1821-1823 | Samuel Prevo | |
| 1823-1825 | Charles Neeley | |
| 1825-1835 | Jacob Harlan | |
| 1835-1837 | Uri Manley | |
| Probate Justices of the Peace | ||
| 1837-1843 | Uri Manley | |
| 1843-1849 | Stephen Archer | |
| County Judges | ||
| 1849-1853 | Stephen Archer | |
| 1853-1854 | John Bartlett | |
| 1854-1857 | John Stockwell | |
| 1857-1869 | William C. Whitlock | |
| 1869-1873 | William R. Griffith | |
| 1873-1877 | Justin Harlan | |
| 1877-1882 | William R. Griffith | |
| 1882-1886 | Ethan A. Sutton | |
| 1886-1894 | Henry Gasaway | |
| 1894-1898 | William T. Hollenbeck | |
| 1898-1902 | J. C. Perdue | |
| 1902-1906 | Everett Connelly | |
| 1906-1914 | Hershel R. Snavely | |
| 1914-1918 | A. L. Ruffner | |
| 1918-1922 | Edward Pearce | |
| 1922-1926 | Harry M. Janney | |
| 1926-1932 | Jed Gard | |
| 1934-1938 | C. A. Williams | |
| 1938-1946 | Theodore Thompson | |
| 1946-1958 | John M. Hollenbeck | |
| 1958-1963 | Zollie O. Arbogast | |
| Associate Judges | ||
| 1964-1967 | Zollie O. Arbogast | |
| 1968-1971 | Caslon K. Bennett | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1988 | Caslon K. Bennett | |
| 1988-1989 | Zollie O. Arbogast | |
| 1990 | James K. Robinson | |
| 1990- | Tracy W. Resch | |
| Coles County Judges | ||
| Judges of Probate | ||
| 1831-1834 | James P. Jones | |
| 1834 | John F. Smyth | |
| 1834-1835 | S. M. Dunbar | |
| 1835-1837 | William Collom | |
| Probate Justices of the Peace | ||
| 1837-1841 | Reuben Canterbury | |
| 1841-1843 | John W. Trower | |
| 1843-1847 | Robert S. Mills | |
| 1847-1849 | William W. Bishop | |
| County Judges | ||
| 1849-1857 | William W. Bishop | |
| 1857-1864 | Gideon Edwards | |
| 1864-1865 | Joshua P. Cooper | |
| 1865-1869 | McHenry Brooks | |
| 1869-1873 | Abner M. Peterson | |
| 1873-1877 | William E. Adams | |
| 1877-1882 | James R. Cunningham | |
| 1882-1886 | Charles Bennett | |
| 1886-1894 | Lapsley C. Henley | |
| 1894-1898 | Sumner S. Anderson | |
| 1898-1902 | John P. Harrah | |
| 1902-1910 | T. N. Cofer | |
| 1910-1922 | John P. Harrah | |
| 1922-1930 | J. B. Lane | |
| 1930-1950 | John T. Kincaid | |
| 1950-1963 | William J. Sunderman | |
| Associate Judges | ||
| 1964-1971 | William J. Sunderman | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1989 | William J. Sunderman | |
| 1989-2003 | Ashton C. Waller | |
| 2004-2017 | Teresa K. Righter | |
| 2018- | Mark E. Bovard | |
| City Judges – Mattoon | ||
| 1898-1902 | James F. Hughes | Mattoon |
| 1902-1906 | Lapsley C. Henley | Mattoon |
| 1906-1907 | Horace S. Clark | Mattoon |
| 1909-1910 | George D. Wilson | Mattoon |
| 1910-1922 | John C. McNutt | Mattoon |
| 1922-1925 | Isaac B. Craig | Mattoon |
| 1925-1936 | Clarence H. Douglas | Mattoon |
| 1936-1963 | Jacob Berkowitz | Mattoon |
| Associate Judges (Mattoon) | ||
| 1964-1971 | Jacob Berkowitz | Mattoon |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges (Mattoon) | ||
| 1971-1976 | Jacob Berkowitz | Mattoon |
| 1977-1991 | Joseph R. Spitz | Mattoon |
| 1992-2011 | Gary W. Jacobs | Mattoon |
| 2012- | Brien J. O’Brien | Mattoon |
| City Judges – Charleston | ||
| 1910-1914 | Charles A. Shuey | Charleston |
| 1914-1918 | Charles A. Quackenbush | Charleston |
| 1918-1922 | John T. Kincaid | Charleston |
| 1922-1930 | Ben F. Anderson | Charleston |
| 1930-1936 | Herbert S. Anderson | Charleston |
| 1936-1960 | C. Wade Barrick | Charleston |
| 1960-1962 | Jack H. Anderson | Charleston |
| Cumberland County Judges | ||
| Probate Justices of the Peace | ||
| 1843 | Elisha H. Starkweather | |
| 1843-1849 | James M. Ward | |
| County Judges | ||
| 1849-1853 | James M. Ward | |
| 1853-1861 | William E. Smith | |
| 1861-1864 | Hiram B. Decius | |
| 1864-1869 | Reuben Bloomfield | |
| 1869-1873 | Wiley Ross | |
| 1873-1882 | John W. Miller | |
| 1882-1886 | Leonidas L. Logan | |
| 1886-1890 | Phillip Welshimer | |
| 1890-1894 | Leonidas L. Logan | |
| 1894-1898 | Gershom Monohon | |
| 1898-1902 | Elias M. McPherson | |
| 1902-1906 | Stephen B. Rariden | |
| 1906-1910 | A. L. Ruffner | |
| 1910-1917 | Stephen B. Rariden | |
| 1917-1918 | Millard C. Everhart | |
| 1918-1930 | Albert F. Bussard | |
| 1930-1942 | Charles M. Connor | |
| 1942-1954 | Millard C. Everhart | |
| 1954-1963 | William J. Hill | |
| Associate Judges | ||
| 1964-1966 | William J. Hill | |
| 1966-1971 | James R. Watson | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1989 | James R. Watson | |
| 1990 | Thomas M. Burke | |
| 1990-2002 | Robert B. Cochonour | |
| 2002-2016 | Millard S. Everhart | |
| 2016- | Jonathan T. Braden | |
| Edgar County Judges | ||
| Judges of Probate | ||
| 1823-1826 | Lewis Murphy | |
| 1826-1827 | William Lowry | |
| 1827-1828 | Smith Shaw | |
| 1828-1837 | Jonathan Mayo | |
| Probate Justices of the Peace | ||
| 1837-1839 | Henry Neville | |
| 1839-1849 | Samuel Connelly | |
| County Judges | ||
| 1849-1853 | Samuel Connelly | |
| 1853-1857 | James Steele | |
| 1857-1861 | A. B. Austin | |
| 1861-1865 | George K. Larkin | |
| 1865-1869 | Andrew Y. Trogdon | |
| 1869-1877 | Robert B. Lamon | |
| 1877-1886 | Andrew Y. Trogdon | |
| 1886-1894 | Andrew J. Hunter | |
| 1894 | Henry Tanner | |
| 1894-1898 | Erasmus G. Rose | |
| 1898-1902 | Stephen I. Headley | |
| 1902-1910 | Walter S. Lamon | |
| 1910-1922 | Daniel V. Dayton | |
| 1922-1946 | Paul B. Lauher | |
| 1946-1963 | Howard T. Ruff | |
| Associate Judges | ||
| 1964-1971 | Howard T. Ruff | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1972 | Howard T. Ruff | |
| 1972-1986 | Carl A. Lund | |
| 1986-2000 | Richard E. Scott | |
| 2000-2006 | H. Dean Andrews | |
| 2006-2022 | Steven L. Garst | |
| 2022- | Mark R. Isaf | |
| Vermilion County Judges | ||
| Judges of Probate | ||
| 1826-1837 | Amos Williams | |
| Probate Justices of the Peace | ||
| 1837-1849 | Norman D. Palmer | |
| County Judges | ||
| 1849-1857 | Guy Merrill | |
| 1857-1858 | Norman D. Palmer | |
| 1858-1863 | Joseph Peters | |
| 1863-1865 | Robert B. Lamon | |
| 1865-1868 | Daniel Clapp | |
| 1868-1882 | Raymond W. Hanford | |
| 1882-1890 | David D. Evans | |
| 1890-1897 | John G. Thompson | |
| 1897-1902 | Morton W. Thompson | |
| 1902-1905 | S. Murray Clark | |
| 1905-1906 | Fred Draper | |
| 1906-1909 | Isaac A. Love | |
| 1909-1918 | Lawrence T. Allen | |
| 1918-1925 | Thomas A. Graham | |
| 1925-1930 | William T. Henderson | |
| 1930-1950 | Harlin M. Steely | |
| 1950-1962 | Frank J. Meyer | |
| 1962-1963 | James K. Robinson | |
| Associate Judges | ||
| 1964-1971 | James K. Robinson | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1987 | James K. Robinson | |
| 1987-1988 | Jerry A. Davis | |
| 1988-2006 | Thomas J. Fahey | |
| 2006-2022 | Nancy S. Fahey | |
| 2023-2024 | Robert E. McIntire | |
| 2024- | Mark S. Goodwin | |
| Probate Judges | ||
| 1910-1914 | Clinton Abernathy | |
| 1914-1930 | Walter J. Bookwalter | |
| 1930-1938 | Ralph M. Jinkins | |
| 1938-1954 | Arthur R. Hall | |
| 1954-1958 | John W. Unger | |
| 1958-1963 | Paul M. Wright | |
| Associate Judges (Probate Seat) | ||
| 1964-1971 | Paul M. Wright | |
| Resident Circuit Court Judges (Probate Seat) | ||
| 1971-1987 | Paul M. Wright | |
| 1987-2000 | John P. O’Rourke | |
| 2000- | Craig H. DeArmond | |
| Clary Judgeship – Resident Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1998-2013 | Michael D. Clary | |
| 2014- | Thomas M. O’Shaughnessy | |
| Associate Circuit Court Judges | ||
| Clark, Edgar, and Cumberland Counties – Magistrates | ||
| 1965-1971 | Henri I. Ripstra | |
| Clark, Edgar, and Cumberland Counties – Associate Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971 | Henri I. Ripstra | |
| 1972-1986 | Richard E. Scott | |
| 1987-2000 | H. Dean Andrews | |
| 2001- | David W. Lewis | |
| Coles County – Magistrates | ||
| 1965-1966 | Mark B. Hunt | |
| 1966-1971 | Thomas M. Burke | |
| Coles County – Associate Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1973 | Thomas M. Burke | |
| 1974-1980 | Tom E. Grace | |
| 1980-1983 | Loren J. Kabbes | |
| 1983-1989 | Ashton C. Waller | |
| 1989-1992 | Gary W. Jacobs | |
| 1993-1996 | Dale A. Cini | |
| 1997-2004 | Teresa K. Righter | |
| 2005-2012 | Brien J. O’Brien | |
| 2012-2018 | Mark E. Bovard | |
| 2019-2022 | Brian L. Bower | |
| 2023- | Christopher L. Wetzel | |
| Vermilion County | ||
| 1965–1967: two positions | 1967–2020: three positions | 2020–Present: four positions | ||
| Vermilion County – Magistrates | ||
| 1965-1971 | John F. Twomey | |
| 1965-1971 | Matthew A. Jurczak | |
| 1967-1971 | Lawrence T. Allen, Jr. | |
| Vermilion County – Associate Circuit Court Judges | ||
| 1971-1973 | John F. Twomey | |
| 1971-1984 | Matthew A. Jurczak | |
| 1971-1984 | Lawrence T. Allen, Jr. | |
| 1974-1986 | Rita B. Garman | |
| 1984-1991 | Joseph C. Moore | |
| 1984-2010 | Joseph P. Skowronski | |
| 1987-1995 | David G. Bernthal | |
| 1991-2009 | James K. Borbely | |
| 1995-2010 | Gordon R. Stipp | |
| 1995-1997 | Joseph C. Moore | |
| 2009-2024 | Mark S. Goodwin | |
| 2010-2024 | Derek J. Girton | |
| 2010- | Karen E. Wall | |
| 2020- | Charles D. Mockbee IV | |
| 2024- | Nicolas J. Boileau | |
| 2024-2025 | Robert E. McIntire | |
| 2025- | Lindsay J. Starwalt | |
| Chief Judges | ||
| 1964-1966 | Robert F. Cotton | |
| 1966-1968 | John F. Spivey | |
| 1968-1972 | Harry I. Hannah | |
| 1972-1976 | Jacob Berkowitz | |
| 1976-1995 | Ralph S. Pearman | |
| 1995-2000 | Richard E. Scott | |
| 2000-2001 | James R. Glenn | |
| 2001-2003 | Ashton C. Waller | |
| 2003-2007 | James R. Glenn | |
| 2007-2011 | Tracy W. Resch | |
| 2011-2015 | Millard S. Everhart | |
| 2015-2017 | Craig H. DeArmond | |
| 2017-2021 | Mitchell K. Shick | |
| 2021-2025 | Thomas M. O’Shaughnessy | |
| 2025- | Mark E. Bovard | |
| Administrative Assistants | ||
| Secretaries | ||
| 1964-1966 | Mildred P. Weston | |
| 1966-1967 | Mildred J. Towle | |
| Administrative Secretaries | ||
| 1967-1968 | Mildred J. Towle | |
| 1968-1985 | Sibyl E. Etchason | |
| Administrative Assistants | ||
| 1985-1991 | Sibyl E. Etchason | |
| 1991-2007 | Ann E. Staats | |
| 2007-2013 | Kathleen A. Lay | |
| 2013-2016 | Rustye D. Cooley | |
| 2016-2019 | Alexander Wakeland | |
| 2019- | Lori J. Pearson | |